Cali-GrafCali-Graf
CalculatorRatesSCENet meteringBatteries

SCE TOU-D-4-9PM vs TOU-D-5-8PM vs TOU-D-PRIME for homes with solar and batteries, October 2026 rates

Cali-Graf · Published Nov 17, 2026 · Data as of Oct 1, 2026

At the rates SCE put in place on October 1, 2026, TOU-D-PRIME is the cheapest of the three time-of-use plans for most single-family homes without solar — those using more than 6,500 to 9,000 kWh a year — and TOU-D-4-9PM is the cheapest for most homes with NEM 2.0 solar. In the inland valleys, a home that uses 9,000 kWh a year pays $3,467 a year on PRIME against $3,523 on 4-9PM, and $244 less on PRIME when it also charges an electric car at night. With NEM 2.0 solar that covers 90% of its use, the same home pays $998 on 4-9PM and $1,144 on PRIME.

PRIME's price per kWh is lower than 4-9PM's in every hour except the summer weekday peak, but PRIME has no baseline credit, which takes $0.091 off each kWh up to the home's baseline allowance on 4-9PM and 5-8PM. Without solar, PRIME comes out ahead once a home uses more than 6,500 to 9,000 kWh a year, depending on the region. With NEM 2.0, solar sent to the grid is credited at the plan's own price for that hour, so PRIME's lower daytime prices make the exported solar worth less. Solar connected under the Net Billing Tariff has no choice: it has to be on PRIME.

$56
Yearly saving on PRIME vs 4-9PM, home without solar using 9,000 kWh a year
SCE inland valleys, rates from Oct 1, 2026
$146
Yearly extra cost of PRIME vs 4-9PM, same home with NEM 2.0 solar covering 90% of use
SCE inland valleys, rates from Oct 1, 2026
7,750
Yearly use in kWh from which PRIME is the lowest plan, home without solar
SCE inland valleys, rates from Oct 1, 2026
In this guide
Who can choose which planHomes without solarHomes with NEM 2.0 solarThe lowest plan in each regionPrice per kWh on each planCheck a home's planData limitsQuestionsMethodologySourcesHow to cite this page

Who can choose which plan#

Homes without solar can take any of the three options of Schedule TOU-D. Since October 1, 2026, Option PRIME has no eligibility condition: Advice 5897-E removed the special condition that limited it to homes with an electric vehicle, a home battery or an electric heat pump. A change of plan takes effect at the next meter read, and a customer who chose a plan stays on it for 12 months before changing again.

Homes with NEM 2.0 solar (Schedule NEM-ST, closed to new customers on April 15, 2023: homes that had submitted a complete interconnection application before that date) must be on a time-of-use plan: 4-9PM by default, or 5-8PM or PRIME.

Homes with solar under the Net Billing Tariff (Schedule NBT, also called the Solar Billing Plan: applications from April 15, 2023) can only be on TOU-D-PRIME.

Model the bill before and after solar
Cali-Graf lays out panels on the roof from satellite imagery, prices the home's use hour by hour on SCE's rates and builds the customer proposal.
Open Cali-Graf

Homes without solar#

Home, yearly use4-9PM5-8PMPRIMELowest
5,000 kWh$1,864$1,866$1,9704-9PM11 of 30 homes
7,000 kWh$2,705$2,696$2,7635-8PM19 of 30 homes
9,000 kWh$3,523$3,521$3,467PRIME28 of 30 homes
13,000 kWh$5,161$5,146$4,897PRIME30 of 30 homes
18,000 kWh$7,234$7,200$6,678PRIME30 of 30 homes
9,000 kWh + EV 3,000 kWh$4,619$4,652$4,375PRIME30 of 30 homes
13,000 kWh + EV 3,000 kWh$6,258$6,277$5,805PRIME30 of 30 homes

Yearly bill on each plan, median of 30 simulated single-family homes in SCE's inland valleys (baseline region 9), each scaled to the yearly use shown; EV — 3,000 kWh a year of charging after the evening peak and before morning. Lowest — the plan with the lowest median bill; under it, in how many of the 30 homes that plan is the lowest. Rates in effect from Oct 1, 2026, held for twelve months; SCE generation; no city utility users tax or California Climate Credit. Source: Cali-Graf engine; SCE Schedule TOU-D.

Download this table (CSV)

Small homes pay a little less on 4-9PM or 5-8PM because the baseline credit covers most of their use: at 5,000 kWh a year, PRIME costs $106 more. From 7,750 kWh a year in the valleys PRIME is the lowest, and the gap grows with use. Every home with an electric car charged at night was cheapest on PRIME, in all four regions.

Homes with NEM 2.0 solar#

Home, yearly use4-9PM5-8PMPRIMELowest
9,000 kWhsolar 60% of use, 3.3 kW$1,736$1,756$1,9044-9PM26 of 30 homes
9,000 kWhsolar 90% of use, 4.9 kW$998$1,036$1,1444-9PM30 of 30 homes
9,000 kWhsolar 100% of use, 5.5 kW$723$766$8934-9PM30 of 30 homes
9,000 kWhsolar 90% of use, 4.9 kW, 13.5 kWh battery$656$694$7224-9PM26 of 30 homes
9,000 kWh + EV 3,000 kWhsolar 90% of use, 6.6 kW$1,130$1,214$1,2854-9PM30 of 30 homes
9,000 kWh + EV 3,000 kWhsolar 90% of use, 6.6 kW, 13.5 kWh battery$786$879$8654-9PM29 of 30 homes
18,000 kWhsolar 90% of use, 9.9 kW, 13.5 kWh battery$1,195$1,193$1,3385-8PM19 of 30 homes

Same homes and rates as above, with south-facing solar sized to produce the share of yearly use shown, billed under NEM 2.0 (Schedule NEM-ST): each month, use minus solar sent to the grid in each time-of-use period, paid or credited at the plan's price without the non-bypassable charges; credits carry forward within the twelve-month NEM period and expire at its end. Battery — 13.5 kWh usable (Tesla Powerwall 3), charged from solar only, holding its charge for the plan's peak hours. Source: Cali-Graf engine; SCE Schedules TOU-D and NEM-ST.

Download this table (CSV)

4-9PM was the lowest in 133 of the 140 NEM 2.0 cases in the four regions, and PRIME in none. A battery narrows the gap, because it moves solar from the hours PRIME prices low to its peak: PRIME costs $66 more than 4-9PM with a battery and $146 more without. Only the largest homes, at 18,000 kWh a year, were sometimes cheaper on 5-8PM, by up to $48 a year; in the valleys, with a battery, the two plans are $2 apart.

The lowest plan in each region#

HomeCoast (region 6)Inland basin (region 8)Valleys (region 9)High desert (region 14)
Without solar, 5,000 kWh5-8PMby $15-8PMby $34-9PMby $25-8PMby $3
Without solar, 9,000 kWhPRIMEby $134PRIMEby $143PRIMEby $54PRIMEby $6
Without solar, 9,000 kWh + EVPRIMEby $325PRIMEby $332PRIMEby $244PRIMEby $198
NEM 2.0, 9,000 kWh, solar 90%4-9PMby $324-9PMby $454-9PMby $384-9PMby $28
NEM 2.0, 9,000 kWh, solar 90% + battery4-9PMby $404-9PMby $424-9PMby $384-9PMby $32
NEM 2.0, 18,000 kWh, solar 90% + battery5-8PMby $485-8PMby $275-8PMby $24-9PMby $28

The plan with the lowest median yearly bill; under it, how much lower it is than the next plan. Regions are SCE baseline regions: 6 — coast (weather of Long Beach), 8 — inland basin (Norwalk), 9 — valleys (West Covina), 14 — high desert (Lancaster). Same homes, rates and billing as above. Source: Cali-Graf engine; SCE Schedule TOU-D and Preliminary Statement, Part H.

Download this table (CSV) · Download all cases: four regions, seven homes, six solar options (CSV)

Price per kWh on each plan#

Time of use4-9PM5-8PMPRIME
Summer weekday peak$0.593$0.726$0.613
Summer weekend peak$0.449$0.519$0.397
Summer other hours$0.333$0.343$0.267
Winter peak$0.508$0.560$0.452
Winter night$0.365$0.377$0.304
Winter 8 a.m. to peak$0.322$0.323$0.251
Baseline credit, subtracted per kWh up to the allowance$0.091$0.091—

Delivery plus SCE generation per kWh, rates in effect from Oct 1, 2026. Summer is June through September. Peak is 4 to 9 p.m. on 4-9PM and PRIME and 5 to 8 p.m. on 5-8PM; in summer it is on-peak on weekdays and mid-peak on weekends and holidays. Winter 8 a.m. to peak is super-off-peak; night is the rest of the winter day. Every plan also has the Fixed Recovery Charge on each kWh and the Base Services Charge, about $24.15 a month. Source: SCE Schedule TOU-D.

Download this table (CSV)

5-8PM has the shortest peak and the highest peak price. PRIME is the cheapest of the three in every period except the summer weekday peak; by the hour, 5-8PM is cheaper from 4 to 5 p.m. and 8 to 9 p.m., which fall outside its shorter peak. That is why PRIME wins for homes that use the grid at night and in the morning, and loses when the grid credits a home's midday solar.

Check a home's plan#

Find the twelve months of use on the SCE bill or account, and whether the solar, if any, is on NEM 2.0 or the Net Billing Tariff (the bill names the tariff). Without solar, PRIME was the lowest from 6,500 kWh a year on the coast and in the inland basin, 7,750 kWh in the valleys and 9,000 kWh in the high desert; a home that charges an electric car at night was cheapest on PRIME at every size compared. With NEM 2.0 solar, 4-9PM was the lowest for every home except some of the largest, at 18,000 kWh a year, where 5-8PM was up to $48 a year lower; PRIME was never the lowest. For the solar and battery inverters on the California Energy Commission's lists, see the CEC solar equipment lists page; for how often new solar comes with a battery, the battery attach rate page.

Data limits#

The bills are for customers who buy their electricity from SCE. Customers of Clean Power Alliance or another community choice aggregator pay SCE for delivery and buy generation from the aggregator at its own prices for each plan, so their totals differ; CARE and FERA discounts, Medical Baseline and the all-electric baseline allowance are not modeled.

The rates are those in effect from October 1, 2026, held for twelve months. Advice 5897-E moves PRIME's prices between periods toward their full cost differences on October 1 of each year through 2029 and does the same for 4-9PM over four years, so the gaps in these tables will shift.

For NEM 2.0 the dollar amounts depend on the month the twelve-month NEM period starts and on the billing option. Starting the period in June or October instead of January changes a plan's yearly bill by up to $347, mostly because credits earned in spring then come at the end of the period and expire; the annual billing option, which nets the year's energy charges and credits, lowers a plan's bill by up to $67. The lowest plan changed in 9 of the 140 cases, all with a battery or with solar at 100% of use, where the plans were within $53 of each other.

The homes are simulated, not metered: hourly profiles of single-family homes from the ResStock model of Los Angeles County by NLR (formerly NREL), the closest 30 by yearly use in the region's climate zone. In the same model, 68% of the county's owner-occupied single-family homes without an electric car in the four regions use more than their region's threshold. A battery charged from the grid without solar and solar under the Net Billing Tariff are not compared.

Is TOU-D-PRIME cheaper than TOU-D-4-9PM?

For a home without solar that uses more than 6,500 to 9,000 kWh a year, depending on the region, and for any home that charges an electric car at night, yes, at the rates in effect from October 1, 2026: a 9,000 kWh home in the inland valleys pays $3,467 a year on PRIME against $3,523 on 4-9PM. For a home with NEM 2.0 solar, no.

Should a home with NEM 2.0 solar switch to PRIME?

No. In every NEM 2.0 case compared here PRIME was not the lowest; for a 9,000 kWh home with solar covering 90% of its use it costs $146 a year more than 4-9PM, and $66 more with a battery.

Can a home with new solar choose its time-of-use plan?

No. Solar connected under the Net Billing Tariff (interconnection applications from April 15, 2023) has to be on TOU-D-PRIME.

Methodology#

Each case is one home, billed on the three options of SCE Schedule TOU-D with the same hourly use, the same solar and the same battery; only the plan's hours and prices change, and the battery holds its charge for its own plan's peak. The home: the 30 single-family homes of the NLR ResStock 2025 release for Los Angeles County (AMY2018 weather year) in the CEC climate zone with the same number as the SCE baseline region, without an electric vehicle, closest to the yearly use by modeled consumption, each scaled to exactly that use; their typical weekday and weekend days by month form twelve months of hourly use from January to December 2027. Electric vehicle charging is added as the same amount every night, spread over the hours after the evening peak and before morning, on all plans alike. Solar faces south at a 20° tilt, with NSRDB typical-year weather at the center of the weather ZIP code, a PVWatts-type model, a DC-to-AC ratio of 1.2 and inverter efficiency of 96%, and is sized so that a year's output equals the share of yearly use shown. The battery stores surplus solar only, keeps 20% in reserve, and in the hours before the plan's peak keeps enough charge for the home's use in the peak. Bills without solar follow Schedule TOU-D: energy by period, the baseline credit up to the region's allowance (4-9PM and 5-8PM), the Fixed Recovery Charge, the Base Services Charge and the state energy surcharge. NEM 2.0 bills follow Schedule NEM-ST: monthly use minus export in each period, priced without the non-bypassable charges; those charges on the hourly import net of export; the baseline credit, the Fixed Recovery Charge and the surcharge on the month's net use; credits carried to later months of the twelve-month period starting in January and expiring at its end; the monthly billing option. Each table value is the median of the 30 homes' yearly bills; the lowest plan is the one with the lowest median. Every value was recomputed by a second implementation that reads the rates from the text of SCE's sheets. Amounts are rounded half up.

Sources#

  1. Southern California Edison — Schedule TOU-D, Time-of-Use Domestic, Cal. P.U.C. sheets 91689-E to 91701-E, effective Oct 1, 2026. https://www.sce.com/regulatory/regulatory-information/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices
  2. Southern California Edison — Advice 5897-E, Implementation of the 2025 General Rate Case Phase 2 and Rate Change on October 1, 2026, submitted Sep 29, 2026 (pages 23–24; Preliminary Statement, Part H, sheets 91543-E and 91544-E). https://www.sce.com/regulatory/regulatory-information/advice-letters/pending
  3. Southern California Edison — Schedule NEM-ST, Net Energy Metering Successor Tariff: Applicability (sheet 87547-E), Rates 1–3 (sheets 66518-E, 74879-E, 65281-E), Special Condition 4, Billing (sheets 87552-E, 87553-E). https://www.sce.com/regulatory/regulatory-information/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices
  4. Southern California Edison — Schedule NBT, Net Billing Tariff: Rates 1.a, Eligible Rates (sheet 89744-E). https://www.sce.com/regulatory/regulatory-information/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices
  5. NLR — ResStock 2025 Release 1, End-Use Load Profiles for the U.S. Building Stock. https://registry.opendata.aws/nrel-pds-building-stock/
  6. NLR — National Solar Radiation Database (NSRDB), typical meteorological year. https://nsrdb.nlr.gov/

How to cite this page#

Cali-Graf. “SCE TOU-D-4-9PM vs TOU-D-5-8PM vs TOU-D-PRIME for homes with solar and batteries, October 2026 rates.” cali-graf.com, updated Nov 17, 2026. https://cali-graf.com/guides/sce-tou-d-4-9pm-vs-5-8pm-vs-prime-solar-battery-homes/