Sizing solar under net billing: why 100% offset is the wrong target
Under SCE's Net Billing Tariff the first kW of solar is worth several times the last. Solar that a home uses as it is made saves the full TOU-D-PRIME price; solar sent to the grid earns the export price, a few cents most of the day. For a home that uses 9,000 kWh a year, solar sized to cover 100% of that use exports 64% of its output, and the kW added between 90% and 100% saves $127 a year, against $446 per kW for the first 30%. Sized to 60% of use, the system saves 78% of what the 100% system saves, for 60% of its price at one price per watt.
Without a battery, the shorter payback is always the smaller system, even at the higher price per watt of small systems: 7.3 years at 30% of use against 13.1 years at 100%. With a battery, which stores midday solar for the evening, the best size moves up to about 90% of use, with a payback of 12.9 years.
In this guide
Saving by system size#
Swipe to see all columns →
| Solar, share of use | Saves, solar | Per added kW | Payback, solar | Saves, with battery | Payback, with battery |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 30%1.6 kW | $736 | $446 | 7.3 | $902 | 24.8 |
| 45%2.5 kW | $914 | $217 | 8.8 | $1,440 | 17.4 |
| 60%3.3 kW | $1,058 | $174 | 10.1 | $1,942 | 14.3 |
| 75%4.1 kW | $1,183 | $152 | 11.3 | $2,326 | 13.1 |
| 90%4.9 kW | $1,290 | $130 | 12.4 | $2,557 | 12.9 |
| 100%5.5 kW | $1,360 | $127 | 13.1 | $2,654 | 13.1 |
| 120%6.6 kW | $1,409 | $45 | 15.2 | $2,760 | 13.9 |
The same modeled home of 9,000 kWh a year in SCE's inland valleys, on the Net Billing Tariff and TOU-D-PRIME, with south-facing solar sized to the share of yearly use shown (kW DC under it) and, in the last two columns, a 13.5 kWh battery. Saves — first-year bill saving against TOU-D-4-9PM without solar. Per added kW — the extra saving of each kW added since the row above; in the first row, the saving per kW of the whole system. Payback — system price over the first-year saving, solar at $3.24 per W DC and the battery at $1,260 per kWh (2026 medians), before tax credits and without rate escalation. Source: Cali-Graf engine; 2026 median prices from California DG Stats.
Why the last kW earns the least#
A small system makes less than the home uses at midday, so almost every kWh replaces power bought at the full price: at 30% of use only 18% of the output goes to the grid. Each kW added after that has a larger share of its output exported at the export price; past 100% of use, almost all of it. The tariff counts imports and exports separately, every hour, so a kWh exported at noon earns the noon export price, a few cents, against the full price of a kWh bought at 7 p.m.; under net metering it earned close to the retail price of its own hour.
A battery changes the size that pays. It moves midday solar into the evening, when PRIME charges its peak price, so the solar that would have been exported is worth the full price again; with a battery the 100% system exports 24% of its output. But a battery needs solar to fill it: with a small system it sits half empty and does not pay for itself.
A size that holds up#
- Without a battery, size to the home's daytime use, not its yearly total; the payback is shortest well below 100%. - With a battery, size so that the battery fills on most days and the home's evening use is covered, around 75–100% of yearly use for this home. - Planning an EV or a heat pump adds use: size to the use the home will have, not only to the past bills. SCE allows a system to make up to 150% of the past year's use, and above 100% asks the customer to state that use will grow within 12 months. - Check the result in dollars, not in offset: the offset share is not what the customer saves.
Data limits#
One modeled home, not real ones: the best size for a real home depends on its hourly use, its roof and its quotes. Every size is priced at one median price per watt, but small systems cost more per watt: in 2025, $3.78 for 2 to 4 kW AC against $3.04 for 8 to 10 kW. That narrows the gap between sizes without reversing it: the 30% system still pays back sooner than the 100% system at any price up to $5.85 per W. The battery price is the median of batteries added to existing solar. Payback is simple — first-year saving, no tax credit, financing, rate escalation or battery replacement — and the export prices are those of the latest published table.
Should solar cover 100% of usage under net billing?
Not without a battery. For a modeled 9,000 kWh SCE home, solar covering all of its use pays back in 13.1 years and exports 64% of its output for a few cents a kWh; a system covering 60% of use saves 78% as much for 60% of the price at one price per watt.
What size solar pays back fastest on SCE's Net Billing Tariff?
Without a battery, the smallest systems, sized to daytime use: 7.3 years at 30% of use in the model. With a battery, about 90% of use, 12.9 years.
Does a battery change how big the solar should be?
Yes. It turns midday exports into evening savings, so it rewards a larger system; a battery with a small system does not fill and does not pay back.
Methodology#
The Cali-Graf engine bills one modeled home in SCE's inland valleys (baseline region 9, typical-year weather at ZIP 91790) for 2027 at SCE's rates of October 1, 2026: TOU-D-4-9PM without solar; with solar, the Net Billing Tariff on TOU-D-PRIME with hourly export prices from the latest published table, the ACC Plus adder for 2027 interconnection requests, monthly billing and the annual true-up; no city utility users tax. The hourly use is built from NLR ResStock profiles of Los Angeles homes scaled to 9,000 kWh. Solar faces south at a 20° tilt and makes 1,638 kWh per kW a year. The battery charges from solar, keeps charge for PRIME's peak and sells to the grid when the export price beats the import price. Prices: 2026 medians of owned solar per W DC and of batteries per kWh in SCE's Los Angeles County territory, from California DG Stats. Amounts are rounded half up.
Sources#
- Southern California Edison — Schedule NBT, Net Billing Tariff, and Schedule TOU-D. https://www.sce.com/regulatory/regulatory-information/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices
- Southern California Edison — Solar Billing Plan export prices. https://www.sce.com/customer-service-center/help-center/solar/solar-billing-plan/understanding-export-pricing
- California Distributed Generation Statistics — Interconnected Project Sites data set, data through Aug 31, 2026. https://www.californiadgstats.ca.gov/downloads/
- NLR — ResStock 2025 Release 1 and NSRDB. https://registry.opendata.aws/nrel-pds-building-stock/
How to cite this page#
Cali-Graf. “Sizing solar under net billing: why 100% offset is the wrong target.” cali-graf.com, updated Nov 17, 2026. https://cali-graf.com/guides/sizing-solar-net-billing-offset/