Cali-GrafCali-Graf
DataNet billingSCESelf-consumptionOrientation

Self-consumption vs export under net billing: testing the rules of thumb

Cali-Graf · Published Nov 17, 2026 · Data as of Oct 1, 2026

Under SCE's Net Billing Tariff, a kWh of solar the home uses itself is worth the retail price of that hour, and a kWh it exports is worth the hour's export price, so where the solar goes decides the saving. Checked hour by hour on a modeled home of 9,000 kWh a year, two of four common rules of thumb hold and two need correcting. An exported kWh earned $0.037 on average against $0.35 for a kWh bought, about a tenth rather than a quarter. The home used 35% of its solar itself with a system sized to its use, but 60% at half that size. West-facing panels made 11% less than south-facing ones of the same size and saved $82 a year more. A kWh of use moved from 7 p.m. to noon on a weekday saved $0.56 in July and $0.39 in January.

$0.037
Average energy export credit per kWh exported (without the ACC Plus adder)
Modeled home, solar sized to its use
35%
Share of its solar the home used itself
Same home, no battery
$82
Extra yearly saving, west-facing vs south-facing
Same system size
In this guide
Rule 1: "An export is worth about a quarter of a kWh bought"Rule 2: "A home uses about a third of its solar"Rule 3: "Under net billing, face the panels west"Rule 4: "Run the dishwasher and the laundry at midday"Data limitsQuestionsMethodologySourcesHow to cite this page

Rule 1: "An export is worth about a quarter of a kWh bought"#

Not on average: about a tenth. With a system that makes as much as the home uses, the export credit came to $0.037 per kWh exported, 11% of the $0.35 the home paid in energy charges per kWh bought. A system that applied to interconnect by the end of 2027 also earns the ACC Plus adder for nine years, $0.008 per kWh exported for a 2027 application, which brings an export to $0.045, 13% of a kWh bought: still nowhere near a quarter. The export price follows the hour: a few cents at midday, when most solar is exported, and above the price of a kWh bought at the same hour only in a few August and September hours, from mid-afternoon into the evening.

Test the roof's orientations hour by hour
Cali-Graf models each roof face hour by hour on the Net Billing Tariff and builds the customer proposal.
Open Cali-Graf

Rule 2: "A home uses about a third of its solar"#

Only when the system is sized to the whole use. The share of solar used in the home falls as the system grows, because the extra output comes at hours when the home already has more than it needs.

System size, share of usekWkWh madeUsed in the homekWh exportedExport credit per kWhSaving per year
50%2.754,50560%1,805$0.031$965
75%4.126,75044%3,774$0.035$1,183
100%5.498,99435%5,815$0.037$1,360
120%6.5910,79630%7,571$0.039$1,409

One modeled home of 9,000 kWh a year with south-facing solar at 20°, billed for 2027 at SCE's rates of October 1, 2026: TOU-D-4-9PM without solar, the Net Billing Tariff on TOU-D-PRIME with it, no battery. Used in the home is the share of the year's solar output not exported; the saving is the bill without solar minus the bill with it, true-up included. Source: Cali-Graf engine.

Download this table (CSV)

At 50% of use, the home used 60% of its solar; at 120%, 30%. Going from 100% to 120% added 1,802 kWh of output and $49 a year of saving.

Rule 3: "Under net billing, face the panels west"#

It holds for the same system. Facing west, the 5.49 kW system made 11% less than facing south, but saved $1,441 a year against $1,360: more of its output came in the afternoon and early evening, when the home uses it and the price of a kWh bought is higher. Each kWh it made saved $0.18, against $0.15 facing south. Southwest did as well as west; east saved $250 a year less than south.

Panels facekWh madeUsed in the homeExport credit per kWhSaving per year
South8,99435%$0.037$1,360
Southwest8,78038%$0.039$1,444
West7,98542%$0.041$1,441
East7,64237%$0.036$1,110

The same home with the same 5.49 kW of solar at 20°, facing each way; rates and billing as in the table above. Source: Cali-Graf engine.

Download this table (CSV)

Rule 4: "Run the dishwasher and the laundry at midday"#

It holds. Moving a kWh of use from 7 p.m. to noon on a weekday saves the price of the kWh no longer bought at 7 p.m., less the export credit the noon kWh no longer earns.

DayPrice of a kWh bought at 7 p.m.Export price at noonSaved per kWh moved
July weekday$0.61$0.053$0.56
January weekday$0.45$0.058$0.39

TOU-D-PRIME prices at SCE's rates of October 1, 2026, delivery plus generation; export price for 2027 on SCE's latest table, delivery plus generation. Assumes the home's solar is exporting at noon. A system that earns the ACC Plus adder also gives up $0.008 per kWh moved, for a 2027 application. Source: SCE Schedule TOU-D and the SCE export price table, as in the Cali-Graf engine.

Download this table (CSV)

With solar exporting at noon, the move is worth more than on a home without solar, where it saves only the difference between the 7 p.m. and noon prices: $0.35 in July and $0.20 in January.

Data limits#

One modeled home at one location, not a real one: a home that is out during the day uses less of its solar than shown, and one with an electric vehicle charged at midday uses more. The orientation test keeps the system the same size; a west roof that holds fewer panels, or shading, changes the result. Export prices are those of SCE's latest table, which changes for systems that apply in later years. Bills are for one year, without a battery.

How much is exported solar worth under SCE's net billing?

In the model, $0.037 per kWh exported on average over the year, about a tenth of what a kWh bought costs, or $0.045 with the ACC Plus adder of a 2027 application; most exports happen at midday, when the export price is a few cents.

Do west-facing solar panels save more under net billing?

For the same system, yes in the model: $82 a year more than south-facing, although they made 11% less, because more of their output is used in the home in the late afternoon.

Is it worth moving electricity use to the middle of the day with solar?

Yes: each kWh moved from 7 p.m. to noon on a weekday saved $0.56 in July and $0.39 in January on TOU-D-PRIME.

Methodology#

The Cali-Graf engine bills one modeled home (NLR ResStock profiles scaled to 9,000 kWh, typical-year weather at ZIP 91790, solar at 20° tilt) hour by hour for 2027 at SCE's rates of October 1, 2026, with SCE generation and no city tax: without solar on TOU-D-4-9PM, with solar on the Net Billing Tariff and TOU-D-PRIME, exports at SCE's latest export price table, the true-up at the end of December. Each hour, solar first meets the home's use and the rest is exported. The export credit per kWh is the year's export credits over the kWh exported; the energy charge per kWh bought leaves out the non-bypassable charges, which export credits cannot pay. Amounts are rounded half up.

Sources#

  1. Southern California Edison — Schedule NBT and Schedule TOU-D (TOU-D-PRIME). https://www.sce.com/regulatory/regulatory-information/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices
  2. Southern California Edison — Solar Billing Plan export prices. https://www.sce.com/customer-service-center/help-center/solar/solar-billing-plan/understanding-export-pricing
  3. NLR — ResStock 2025 Release 1 and NSRDB. https://registry.opendata.aws/nrel-pds-building-stock/

How to cite this page#

Cali-Graf. “Self-consumption vs export under net billing: testing the rules of thumb.” cali-graf.com, updated Nov 17, 2026. https://cali-graf.com/guides/self-consumption-vs-export-net-billing/