Battery without solar: TOU arbitrage economics in SCE territory
A home battery without solar can still save money on an SCE bill: it charges from the grid when power is cheap and runs the home through the 4–9 p.m. peak. On the bill saving alone, it does not pay for itself. In our model, a 13.5 kWh battery saves the median home of 9,000 kWh a year $522 a year against the cheapest plan without it, so at the median price of $17,689 it takes 34 years to pay back, against a 10-year warranty. A home using 12,000 kWh saves $649 (27 years); one using 6,000 kWh, $223 (79 years).
In this guide
What a kWh moved to the evening is worth#
Swipe to see all columns →
| Plan and day | Price at 6 p.m. | Cheapest price before 4 p.m. | Same, with round-trip losses | Saved per kWh delivered |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PRIME, summer weekday | $0.624 | $0.278 | $0.313 | $0.311 |
| PRIME, winter day | $0.463 | $0.262 | $0.295 | $0.169 |
| 4-9PM, summer weekday | $0.605 | $0.344 | $0.387 | $0.218 |
| 4-9PM, winter day | $0.520 | $0.334 | $0.375 | $0.145 |
Price per kWh bought on each plan at SCE's rates of October 1, 2026, delivery plus generation and the per-kWh charges billed with them, before TOU-D-4-9PM's baseline credit; the cheapest price is the lowest hour of the same day before 4 p.m. Round-trip losses at the battery's 89% efficiency. Source: SCE Schedule TOU-D; Cali-Graf battery reference.
On TOU-D-PRIME, a summer weekday kWh at 6 p.m. costs $0.62 and the same kWh bought in the morning $0.28, so each kWh the battery delivers in the peak saves $0.31 after losses; on a winter day, $0.17. Over the year the median 9,000 kWh home saved $0.21 per kWh delivered, over 188 full cycles.
The saving by home size#
Swipe to see all columns →
| Home use, kWh a year | Bill, best plan without battery | Bill with battery | Battery saves a year | Cycles a year | Payback, years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6,000 | $2,236 | $2,016 | $223 | 106 | 79 |
| 9,000 | $3,467 | $2,923 | $522 | 188 | 34 |
| 12,000 | $4,529 | $3,878 | $649 | 240 | 27 |
Median of 30 modeled homes of each size: NLR ResStock homes of SCE's baseline region 9 (inland valleys), scaled to the yearly use, no solar, no electric vehicle. Bills for 2027 at SCE's rates of October 1, 2026, without city tax or the Climate Credit. The battery: Tesla Powerwall 3, 13.5 kWh, charging from the grid at up to 5 kW, keeping 20% for outages and never exporting. Without the battery, each home is on its cheapest of the three TOU-D plans; with it, on its cheapest plan with the battery. Payback is the price of $17,689 over the yearly saving, without incentives, financing or rate changes. The saving is the median of each home's own saving, so it is not the difference of the two median bills. Source: Cali-Graf model; battery price — median total cost of 13.5 kWh batteries added to existing solar in SCE's Los Angeles County territory, connected from January 2025 to August 2026 (California DG Stats); at the 2026 median per kWh, $17,010, the 9,000 kWh home's payback is 33 years.
The saving grows with use because a bigger home has more evening load for the battery to cover; a home of 6,000 kWh uses less in the peak than the battery holds on most days. A battery that keeps no backup reserve saves the 9,000 kWh home $544 instead of $522.
Which plan#
Since October 1, 2026, TOU-D-PRIME is open to every SCE home, so the battery no longer unlocks it: without a battery, the median 9,000 kWh home already saves $55 a year on PRIME against TOU-D-4-9PM. With the battery, PRIME was the cheapest plan for 30 of 30 homes of 9,000 kWh, while 29 of 30 homes of 6,000 kWh stayed cheapest on TOU-D-4-9PM, whose baseline credit matters more to a small home.
Swipe to see all columns →
| Plan | Without battery | With battery | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| TOU-D-4-9PM | $3,523 | $3,104 | $419 |
| TOU-D-5-8PM | $3,521 | $3,144 | $377 |
| TOU-D-PRIME | $3,467 | $2,923 | $545 |
The median 9,000 kWh home on each plan, with and without the battery; inputs as in the table above. Source: Cali-Graf model.
Data limits#
The homes are modeled, not real: a home that is empty in the evening, or runs air conditioning late into the night, saves less or more. The battery follows one simple daily rule: it charges in the cheapest hours of the day before the plan's peak (4 p.m., or 5 p.m. on TOU-D-5-8PM) as much as it will deliver, then covers the home's load in the peak hours. Battery apps follow similar time-of-use schedules but are not identical. The battery price is the median for a battery added to a home that already has solar; a battery on its own can cost more, for example for a backup gateway. Not included: incentives such as SGIP, payments from demand response programs, the value of backup power, battery wear and the critical-peak-pricing versions of the plans.
Does a home battery without solar save money in SCE territory?
Yes, in the model: charged from the grid in cheap hours and used in the 4–9 p.m. peak, a 13.5 kWh battery saved a median 9,000 kWh home $522 a year against its cheapest plan without a battery.
How long does a battery take to pay back on time-of-use savings alone?
About 34 years for a 9,000 kWh home at the median battery price of $17,689, and 27 years for a 12,000 kWh home: longer than the battery's 10-year warranty. Incentives, demand response payments or backup value have to make up the difference.
Which SCE rate plan is best for a battery without solar?
TOU-D-PRIME for most homes in the model; homes using around 6,000 kWh a year did better on TOU-D-4-9PM because of its baseline credit.
Methodology#
Loads: 30 NLR ResStock homes of SCE baseline region 9 for each size, scaled to the yearly use, hour by hour for 2027. Bills: the Cali-Graf SCE billing engine on TOU-D-4-9PM, TOU-D-5-8PM and TOU-D-PRIME at the rates of October 1, 2026 (Advice 5897-E), baseline region 9, SCE generation, no city tax. Battery: the Powerwall 3 of the Cali-Graf battery reference (13.5 kWh usable, 5 kW charge from the grid, 89% round-trip efficiency, 20% reserve), dispatched each day as described under Data limits; it never exports. The bill difference on TOU-D-PRIME was checked against a separate hour-by-hour sum of the moved kWh times their prices: they agree within $0.13 a year for every home. Payback: battery price over the median yearly saving. Amounts are rounded half up.
Sources#
- Southern California Edison — Schedule TOU-D (Advice 5897-E, effective October 1, 2026). https://www.sce.com/regulatory/regulatory-information/tariff-books/rates-pricing-choices
- Tesla — Powerwall 3 datasheet. https://www.tesla.com/powerwall
- California Distributed Generation Statistics — Interconnected Project Sites data set. https://www.californiadgstats.ca.gov/downloads/
- NLR — ResStock 2025 Release 1. https://registry.opendata.aws/nrel-pds-building-stock/
How to cite this page#
Cali-Graf. “Battery without solar: TOU arbitrage economics in SCE territory.” cali-graf.com, updated Nov 18, 2026. https://cali-graf.com/guides/battery-without-solar-sce-tou-arbitrage/